'Wow'… Jamie Carragher snubs Liverpool to make major Newcastle United admission

Newcastle United’s victory over Liverpool in the Carabao Cup final wasn’t just a win—it was a statement. After years of frustration, Eddie Howe’s side finally broke their winless streak against the Reds, securing a historic 2-1 triumph at Wembley in March.

That moment didn’t just deliver silverware; it signaled a turning point for the Magpies, igniting hopes of a new era under PIF’s ambitious ownership.

Now, with Champions League qualification within reach and an outside shot at a second-place Premier League finish, Newcastle’s resurgence has caught the attention of even the most unlikely admirers—including Liverpool legend Jamie Carragher.

Carragher’s Bold Declaration: Newcastle Over Liverpool

Few expected Carragher, a lifelong Liverpool stalwart, to anoint Newcastle United as the Premier League’s standout team this season. Yet, during a recent episode of It’s Called Soccer on the Overlap US YouTube channel, the former defender made a compelling case for the Magpies.

When asked to name his team of the season, Carragher didn’t hesitate. “I think it could be Newcastle,” he admitted. “They could end up second or third. If you had told me at the start of the season that Newcastle would finish third and win a trophy, I’d have said ‘wow.’ Given the competition in the league, that’s extraordinary.”

He went further, highlighting the challenges Newcastle overcame—financial constraints, Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR) complications, and a summer transfer window that saw them juggle sales rather than splurge on marquee signings. “The fact they won a trophy—I’ll go Newcastle,” Carragher concluded, a statement that speaks volumes about their achievements.

Carragher’s praise isn’t just about results—it’s a nod to Eddie Howe’s transformative impact. When the former Bournemouth manager took charge in 2021, Newcastle were languishing in the relegation zone. Fast-forward to today, and they’re competing with Europe’s elite while ending a 54-year domestic trophy drought.

Newcastle United’s Swedish striker #14 Alexander Isak (R) celebrates after scoring his team second goal during the English League Cup final football match between Liverpool and Newcastle United at Wembley Stadium, north-west London on March 16, 2025. (Photo by Glyn KIRK / AFP) / RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE. No use with unauthorized audio, video, data, fixture lists, club/league logos or ‘live’ services. Online in-match use limited to 120 images. An additional 40 images may be used in extra time. No video emulation. Social media in-match use limited to 120 images. An additional 40 images may be used in extra time. No use in betting publications, games or single club/league/player publications. / (Photo by GLYN KIRK/AFP via Getty Images)

Unsurprisingly, Howe’s work hasn’t gone unnoticed. Newcastle icon Alan Shearer recently argued on The Rest Is Football podcast that Howe should be a frontrunner for Manager of the Season—especially if the Magpies secure a top-three finish alongside their Carabao Cup glory.

“If Newcastle finish second and win the Carabao Cup, does that not make Eddie Howe manager of the season?” Shearer challenged. Co-host Gary Lineker conceded the point, though he noted the award traditionally favors the Premier League-winning manager.

Howe vs. Slot: The Managerial Debate

While Howe’s case is strong, Liverpool’s Arne Slot remains the favorite for the accolade. The Dutchman, in his debut season at Anfield, seamlessly filled the void left by Jürgen Klopp, steering the Reds to the title with minimal squad changes. His ability to maintain dominance without a major overhaul is undeniably impressive.

Yet, history shows the award isn’t exclusively reserved for title-winning managers. Alan Pardew claimed it in 2012 after guiding Newcastle to an unexpected fifth-place finish—proof that exceptional overachievement can defy convention.

Newcastle’s rise isn’t just about breaking records—it’s about rewriting narratives. For years, the club was synonymous with unfulfilled potential. Now, they’re a force, blending tactical intelligence with relentless ambition.

Carragher’s endorsement underscores just how far they’ve come. When a Liverpool legend tips Newcastle as the season’s standout team, it’s clear something special is unfolding at St. James’ Park. Whether it’s Howe’s tactical acumen, the squad’s resilience, or the newfound belief coursing through the stands, the Magpies are no longer underdogs—they’re contenders.