Newcastle United defender labelled ’embarrassing’ after recent performances
Lloyd Kelly’s career trajectory has taken an unexpected downturn since his January loan move to Juventus, with the defender becoming the target of scathing criticism from Italian media.
What began as an exciting opportunity at one of Europe’s most prestigious clubs has transformed into a nightmare stint for the 26-year-old, whose performances have been branded “embarrassing” by prominent Serie A observers.
The former Bournemouth center-back arrived at Newcastle last summer with high hopes, reuniting with manager Eddie Howe who had previously worked with him on the South Coast.
Yet despite showing flashes of potential during his limited appearances, Kelly failed to establish himself as a regular starter at St James’ Park. His 14 appearances for the Magpies told the story of a player struggling to adapt to the demands of a top-six Premier League side, prompting Newcastle’s decision to loan him to Juventus – a move that has backfired spectacularly for the player.
Italian journalist Mimmo Cugini delivered the most damning assessment of Kelly’s time in Turin: “Considering what they paid for him, I think he is the most disastrous signing in Juventus history.
The goal he conceded against Parma represented amateur-level defending at best.” These comments followed a string of underwhelming performances that have seen Kelly become the scapegoat for Juventus’ defensive frailties.
Remarkably, despite this torrent of criticism, Juventus appear set to make Kelly’s move permanent for approximately £20 million – a deal that represents excellent business for Newcastle.
The Magpies will recoup a significant fee for a player who cost nothing in transfer fees last summer and failed to make an impact in their first team. This financial windfall could prove crucial as Newcastle look to reinvest in their squad while navigating Financial Fair Play regulations.
Kelly’s impending departure opens the door for potential defensive reinforcements, with reports linking Newcastle to AC Milan’s Fikayo Tomori. The England international would represent a significant upgrade, bringing Champions League experience and proven quality at the highest level.
Tomori’s potential arrival would complete a defensive overhaul that has already seen Newcastle secure Sven Botman and Dan Burn in recent seasons.
The contrast between Kelly’s failed Italian adventure and Tomori’s potential move to Tyneside highlights the ruthless nature of modern football transfers. While one defender exits with his reputation damaged, another could arrive with the pedigree to immediately improve Newcastle’s backline.
For Kelly, the coming months represent a critical juncture – whether he can resurrect his career in Serie A or needs to seek redemption elsewhere remains to be seen.
Newcastle’s handling of the situation demonstrates shrewd squad management. Recognizing Kelly’s limitations, they’ve positioned themselves to profit from his sale while identifying a superior replacement.
In the high-stakes world of Premier League football, such calculated decisions often separate progressive clubs from stagnant ones. As the summer transfer window approaches, the Magpies appear poised to turn one defensive disappointment into an opportunity for meaningful improvement.