Newcastle exploring move for £25m huge talent, it’d be a better signing than McGinn
As Newcastle United navigate a turbulent summer transfer window, their search for midfield reinforcements has taken an intriguing turn toward Ajax’s Kenneth Taylor.
The 23-year-old Dutch international represents a compelling alternative to primary target John McGinn, offering a different profile that could better suit Eddie Howe’s long-term vision for the Magpies’ engine room.
The departure of Sean Longstaff to Leeds United has left Newcastle light in midfield, particularly with the added demands of Champions League football looming.
While Aston Villa captain McGinn initially appeared the obvious target, his £30 million valuation and £120,000 weekly wages give pause for a player who would likely serve as a squad option rather than an automatic starter.
Taylor’s credentials present an intriguing contrast to the Scottish international:
| Midfield Comparison | Kenneth Taylor (Ajax) | John McGinn (Aston Villa) |
|---|---|---|
| Age | 23 | 30 |
| 2024/25 Goals | 9 | 1 |
| 2024/25 Assists | 6 | 4 |
| Pass Completion % | 83% | 87% |
| Key Passes per Game | 1.1 | 0.9 |
| Market Value | £25m | £30m+ |
| Weekly Wages | £45k | £120k |
The data reveals Taylor as a more progressive, attack-minded option compared to McGinn’s combative style. The Ajax academy product finished last season ranked among Europe’s elite midfielders in several key metrics:
- Top 1% for goals scored among midfielders
- Top 7% for through balls completed
- Top 2% for goal-creating actions
His playing style draws comparisons to Joelinton, combining physical presence with technical quality – a blend that would complement Bruno Guimaraes and Sandro Tonali perfectly.
Taylor’s ability to contribute in the final third (15 goals, 8 assists last season) offers Newcastle an additional attacking dimension they’ve lacked from midfield.
Financially, Taylor represents better value for a club needing to allocate resources across multiple positions. His £25 million valuation and modest wages allow Newcastle to strengthen elsewhere while securing a player whose peak years still lie ahead.
McGinn’s leadership qualities and Premier League experience are undeniable, but at 30, he offers limited resale value and would likely block pathways for emerging talents like Lewis Miley.
Taylor’s development trajectory suggests he could evolve into one of Europe’s premier midfielders under Howe’s guidance.
Having captained Ajax at just 22 and won back-to-back Player of the Season awards, he’s demonstrated maturity beyond his years.
His familiarity with European competition and comfort in possession-based systems make him an ideal fit for Newcastle’s aspirations.
As the Magpies prepare for their Champions League return, Taylor’s energy and creativity could prove invaluable in balancing domestic and continental commitments.
While defensive reinforcements and a striker remain priorities, securing a midfielder of Taylor’s potential now could prevent Newcastle from facing another scramble in future windows.
The coming weeks will reveal whether Newcastle opt for McGinn’s ready-made Premier League quality or take a calculated gamble on Taylor’s higher ceiling.
In a summer where long-term planning must balance immediate needs, the Dutchman’s blend of youth, technical quality, and attacking threat makes a compelling case for being the smarter investment.