Manager who was 'really close' to beating Eddie Howe to Newcastle job faces seven month ban after meltdown

Eddie Howe secured the Newcastle United managerial role in 2021 after beating out several high-profile candidates. Following the PIF takeover, it seemed inevitable that the club’s new owners would seek a fresh start with a new head coach.

As Steve Bruce recognized his tenure at St. James’ Park was nearing its conclusion, he personally recommended Howe as his successor. PIF ultimately took his advice, and three years later, Newcastle has thrived under Howe’s leadership. Now, he stands on the brink of ending the club’s 70-year trophy drought in the upcoming Carabao Cup final.

The managerial search could have led Newcastle down an entirely different path had they opted for another candidate. Antonio Conte, one of the names under consideration, has since returned to Italy and is leading a title challenge.

Another option at the time, Paulo Fonseca, now finds himself embroiled in controversy and facing a lengthy suspension due to an incident that has stunned the football world.

Fonseca, currently managing Lyon, faces a potential seven-month ban following an altercation with referee Benoit Millot during his team’s 2-1 victory over Brest. In a moment of frustration, he confronted the official and aggressively pushed his head toward him, an act that has drawn severe consequences.

Lyon’s Portuguese head coach Paulo Fonseca (R) yells at French referee Benoit Millot (L) after receiving a red card during the French L1 football match between Olympique Lyonnais (OL) and Stade Brestois 29 (Brest) at the Parc Olympique lyonnais in Decines-Charpieu, central-eastern France on March 2, 2025. (Photo by JEFF PACHOUD / AFP) (Photo by JEFF PACHOUD/AFP via Getty Images)

French media outlets report that disciplinary action is imminent, with the punishment expected to be handed down swiftly.

This incident stands in stark contrast to Newcastle’s own disciplinary concerns, particularly regarding Anthony Gordon’s recent red card against Brighton in the FA Cup. While Gordon’s actions frustrated fans, they pale in comparison to the severity of Fonseca’s misconduct. The situation serves as a reminder of the volatility that can come with certain managerial choices.

Fonseca was once on the verge of becoming Newcastle’s head coach, having impressed Amanda Staveley during the interview process. Reports suggested that Newcastle was prepared to offer the Portuguese coach a lucrative £6 million-per-season contract, positioning him as the frontrunner for the job. However, the club ultimately pivoted toward other

candidates, including Unai Emery and Eddie Howe. While some fans were initially intrigued by the prospect of Fonseca’s attacking philosophy, there is little regret now given the progress made under Howe.

Howe has not only stabilized the club but also restored a sense of identity and ambition. His calm and composed demeanor on the touchline reflects the kind of leadership Newcastle needed.

The contrast between his approach and Fonseca’s recent actions highlights the importance of temperament in high-pressure situations. As Newcastle continues its pursuit of silverware, the decision to appoint Howe looks more justified than ever.