Newcastle United’s impressive 2-0 victory over Tottenham Hotspur in the Carabao Cup sparked a wave of intriguing reactions from BBC Sport readers, particularly from self-proclaimed neutrals.
This time, unlike many previous occasions, the feedback wasn’t dominated by the usual political noise surrounding Newcastle’s ownership. Instead, the conversation revolved almost entirely around football the team’s performance, their players, and the continued rise under Eddie Howe’s management.
In the past, BBC Sport comment sections often turned into battlegrounds where Newcastle fans were criticised not for their club’s footballing merits but for the identity of the owners.
Accusations, lectures, and moral posturing became a recurring theme. However, following this latest win, the mood seemed to shift. The neutrals, and even a few rival supporters, focused on what happened on the pitch praising the team’s energy, work ethic, and the brilliant execution that sealed their passage to the quarterfinals once again.
Many readers highlighted the influence of Eddie Howe, calling him an exceptional manager who has elevated nearly every player under his guidance.
One fan commented that almost every footballer joining Newcastle seems to improve beyond expectations, proving that Howe’s management is rooted in genuine player development rather than reputation.
Others singled out the recruitment, noting that Woltemade’s form has made him one of the most effective striker signings of the season.
The comments also captured the humour and banter typical of British football culture. One witty remark compared Woltemade to “Rudi Völler on stilts,” while another joked that “The Toon Army don’t need Isak genuine respect from an Irons fan.”
There were also jabs aimed at Spurs, particularly at players like Richarlison, who some commenters harshly claimed “isn’t Premier League quality.” Even Tottenham supporters joined in the discussion, with a few admitting the team deserved nothing from the game and acknowledging Newcastle’s superiority on the night.
Amid the light-hearted banter, there was also tactical appreciation. Several readers praised Newcastle’s ability to capitalise on set pieces, pointing out that teams capable of scoring and defending effectively in those moments always tend to finish higher in the table.
The defensive discipline, combined with Tonali’s smooth control in midfield, drew admiration from many, with one reader describing him as “as smooth as a Rolls Royce.” Others humorously countered that claim with tongue-in-cheek remarks referencing Granit Xhaka, showing how football debates never lose their playful edge.
Some commenters couldn’t resist mocking Tottenham’s time-wasting antics, especially the now-infamous incident where Spence took too long to tie his bootlaces.
“My five-year-old son can tie his laces quicker,” wrote one fan, while another added, “There’s no rule saying everyone has to wait for a player to fix his boots.” The moment became symbolic of Spurs’ overall sluggish display, with another fan writing, “Got what they deserved for wasting time.”
While the majority of the discussion centred on football, a few still couldn’t resist slipping in remarks about Newcastle’s Saudi ownership. However, these comments were swiftly countered by others who pointed out the irony of criticising the club while benefitting from the same economic ties that fuel modern football.
The tone overall, though, remained focused on the game rather than the politics a refreshing change that many Newcastle fans would likely appreciate.
Beyond the jokes and jabs, there was a sense of admiration for how far Newcastle have come. Several supporters of other clubs expressed their respect for the team’s progress, describing the current squad as one that “plays with purpose, fights for every ball, and earns every win.”
Even a few Spurs fans conceded that Newcastle “deserved the win” and wished them luck in defending their Carabao Cup title.
Perhaps the most telling comment came from a Forest fan who summed up the general mood: “Spurs also rotated heavily and had five academy players on the bench.
But fight is a basic fundamental no matter what team is put out. Newcastle are in a good place all the best in retaining the trophy.”
That single sentiment captures what many neutrals seem to be realising this Newcastle United team isn’t just about ambition or money. It’s about smart management, strong mentality, and a collective spirit that’s winning over even their harshest critics.
For once, the conversation around the Magpies wasn’t about ownership, wealth, or controversy. It was about football and Newcastle United were at the heart of it for all the right reasons.
