Howe may have made a bigger mistake than Minteh by selling “throwback” Newcastle star

Newcastle United recently endured a 4-0 defeat to Manchester City, a game in which they struggled to impose themselves offensively. The Magpies managed only three shots, generated a meager 0.48 xG, and held just 38% of possession.

While Alexander Isak has been a standout performer this season, the match exposed Newcastle’s reliance on him, as Manchester City effectively neutralized his threat. With Anthony Gordon and Jacob Murphy unable to fill the void, the team lacked the attacking variation needed to challenge a side of City’s caliber.

A different option in attack might have made a significant difference, particularly one that could stretch City’s defense on the break from both flanks. Ironically, Newcastle had such a player in their ranks but allowed him to leave in the summer transfer window.

Yankuba Minteh, a young talent with the attributes to excel in these situations, was sold without ever making an appearance for the club.

Newcastle sold Minteh to Brighton & Hove Albion in the summer as part of their efforts to comply with PSR regulations. The Gambian winger departed for a fee of approximately £30 million and has since thrived in Brighton’s system.

Over 23 appearances this season, Minteh has scored five goals, provided three assists, and logged 1,169 minutes on the pitch. His blistering pace, ability to exploit transitions, and knack for finding dangerous areas—whether through dribbling or well-timed runs—make him a consistent threat, particularly on the right flank. Newcastle’s current setup could undoubtedly benefit from such a dynamic presence in attack.

However, Newcastle’s decision to part ways with Chris Wood may represent an even greater oversight. The striker initially left for Nottingham Forest on loan during the 2023/24 season, with an obligation to buy for around £15 million, contingent on certain conditions.

Wood’s stint at Newcastle had been unremarkable, producing just five goals in 39 appearances. Yet, since joining Forest, the 31-year-old has undergone a remarkable transformation. Across 69 games, he has scored 34 goals, provided three assists, and accumulated 4,639 minutes of game time.

This season alone, Wood has netted 18 goals, making him the third-highest scorer in the Premier League and propelling Nottingham Forest into third place after 25 matches.

Wood’s clinical finishing and physical presence could have offered Newcastle a valuable alternative when Isak struggles. Moreover, deploying both players together might have given Eddie Howe more tactical flexibility.

Wood’s ability to convert chances at a high rate and battle defenders in the penalty area makes him the type of player Newcastle now lacks. Former Tottenham and West Ham manager Harry Redknapp once described Wood as a “throwback” striker, someone who thrives in traditional forward roles while consistently delivering results.

Ex-Newcastle Players’ 2024/25 Performances

The table highlights the impressive contributions of several former Newcastle players this season. Beyond Wood and Minteh, players like Aleksandar Mitrovic and Ivan Toney have showcased their scoring prowess, while others, such as Allan Saint-Maximin, have provided creativity and dynamism.

Newcastle’s decision to sell these talents underscores the challenges of assembling a squad capable of sustaining success in both domestic and European competitions.

Newcastle could have retained a mix of different striker profiles and wingers to complement their current squad. Players like Minteh and Wood would have provided contrasting options to Isak, while creative midfielders such as Elliot Anderson could have offered additional ball-carrying quality. With the likes of Murphy and Gordon unable to consistently step up, these former players might have helped bridge the gap in key moments.

Hindsight and Lessons Learned

While it is easy to criticize decisions with the benefit of hindsight, the numbers speak for themselves. Retaining Wood alongside Isak could have bolstered Newcastle’s attack, potentially securing another top-four finish and Champions League qualification.

The sale of Minteh, a player brimming with potential, further highlights the delicate balance between financial compliance and maintaining squad depth.

Newcastle’s journey this season illustrates the fine margins in football. Decisions in the transfer market can have far-reaching consequences, and the club must carefully evaluate its long-term strategy to ensure sustainable success.

As they aim to build on their recent progress, striking the right balance between developing talent and acquiring proven performers will remain critical to their ambitions.