Anthony Gordon penalty incident at Old Trafford – PL panel rule on decision
Anthony Gordon’s performance at Old Trafford on Wednesday night sparked intense debate, not just for his goal but for a critical moment that could have changed the game’s outcome.
In the first half, Anthony Gordon broke into Manchester United’s penalty area with a clear sight of goal. Just as he prepared to shoot, Sofyan Amrabat challenged from behind, causing Gordon to go down. The referee, Robert Jones, did not award a penalty, nor did the VAR official, Jarred Gillett, suggest a review on the pitchside monitor.
Newcastle United Reactions Outrage
The decision left Anthony Gordon, his teammates, and Newcastle United fans in disbelief. Replays showed Amrabat’s studs clearly raking down Gordon’s Achilles, seemingly warranting a penalty. The visibly damaged sock worn by Gordon served as physical evidence of the contact.
Premier League Panel Review
Despite the outcry, a Premier League panel reviewed the incident and concluded that the referee’s decision was correct. According to BBC Sport’s report on May 18, 2024, the panel consisted of five members, only one of whom believed Amrabat’s challenge was enough to impede Gordon and justify a penalty. The other four panelists, along with the VAR’s non-intervention, supported the no-penalty decision unanimously.
Match Outcome and Statistics
Manchester United secured a 3-2 victory over Newcastle United. Here are the match details and key statistics:
Manchester United 3 – 2 Newcastle United
Date: Wednesday, May 15, 8 PM
Goals:
- Newcastle United: Gordon (49′), Hall (90+2′)
- Manchester United: Mainoo (31′), Amad (57′), Hojlund (84′)
Possession:
- Manchester United: 45%
- Newcastle United: 55%
Total Shots:
- Manchester United: 17
- Newcastle United: 21
Shots on Target:
- Both teams: 8
Corners:
- Both teams: 9
Referee: Robert Jones
Newcastle United Lineup:
- Dubravka, Trippier (Schar 63), Krafth, Burn, Hall, Longstaff (Barnes 77), Bruno, Anderson (Joelinton 62), J Murphy (Almiron 62), Gordon, Isak
Unused Subs: Pope, Dummett, Ritchie, White, A Murphy
Analysis: A Missed Opportunity?
The panel’s decision not to award a penalty has been met with widespread skepticism. Many argue that such clear infractions should be penalized to maintain the integrity of the game. The incident raises questions about the consistency and transparency of VAR decisions in the Premier League.
The controversy surrounding Anthony Gordon’s denied penalty at Old Trafford highlights the ongoing challenges with officiating and VAR in football. As Newcastle United reflects on what might have been, the debate over this decision will likely continue among fans and pundits alike.
Read Also: Opinion: Anthony Gordon VAR incident was a disgrace on the night, Rewarded instead of being punished
Read Also: Opinion: Why Did Newcastle United Not Signed Any New Players
Read Also: Opinion: 0 duels won, 17x possession lost: Howe must now ruthlessly ditch out Newcastle’s 6/10 dud
