Newcastle set to launch bid for £43m “pressing monster”, he’d be better than Pedro

Newcastle United’s summer transfer window has begun with frustration rather than fireworks. Despite their Champions League qualification and Carabao Cup triumph, the Magpies have already faced setbacks in the market most notably losing out on João Pedro to Chelsea.

However, with the window still young, Eddie Howe’s side has time to regroup and secure a high-caliber forward to bolster their attack.

While Alexander Isak remains untouchable amid persistent interest from top clubs, Newcastle urgently need a reliable partner for the Swedish striker.

The search has led them to two contrasting options: free agent Dominic Calvert-Lewin and Liverpool’s Diogo Jota. Both present intriguing possibilities, but only one truly aligns with Newcastle’s ambitions.

Newcastle have reportedly considered a move for Dominic Calvert-Lewin following his Everton departure. At 28, the England international offers Premier League experience, but his recent record raises concerns.

Calvert-Lewin’s fitness struggles and declining output make him a gamble. While his physicality and aerial prowess could complement Isak, Newcastle must weigh whether his injury-prone history justifies the investment—especially when more clinical options exist.

Diogo Jota: The Ideal Alternative

If Newcastle seek a proven, high-level forward, Diogo Jota stands out as the superior choice. The Liverpool attacker, though also prone to injuries, has consistently delivered when fit. His intelligent movement, pressing intensity, and versatility across the front line make him an ideal fit for Howe’s system.

Jota’s underlying numbers further highlight his value. Last season, he ranked among Europe’s top forwards in:

• Shots per 90 (top 11%)
• Progressive passes (top 15%)
• Progressive carries (top 11%)
• Tackles per 90 (top 18%)

Dubbed a “pressing monster” by former Liverpool assistant Pep Lijnders, Jota thrives in high-energy systems—making him a seamless fit for Howe’s tactical approach. His Champions League experience would also be invaluable as Newcastle prepare for Europe’s elite competition.

Why Jota Makes More Sense Than Calvert-Lewin

While both forwards have faced injury issues, Jota’s productivity when available far outweighs Calvert-Lewin’s recent struggles. The Portuguese forward offers:

• Proven goal threat – Even in an inconsistent season, he contributed crucial goals.
• Tactical flexibility – Can play across the front three, easing rotation demands.
• Big-game pedigree – Delivered in high-pressure matches for Liverpool.

Newcastle don’t need Jota to start every game—they need a reliable deputy who can elevate the attack when called upon. His ability to link play, press defenders, and score in tight spaces would perfectly complement Isak’s poaching instincts.

Missing out on João Pedro was a blow, but in Jota, Newcastle could land a player who not only matches Pedro’s creativity but surpasses it in terms of end product and experience. Liverpool’s reported £43m asking price is steep, but for a forward of Jota’s caliber, it may prove a shrewd investment.

Meanwhile, Calvert-Lewin remains a fallback option—one that carries significant risk. If Newcastle are serious about competing on multiple fronts, they must prioritize quality over convenience.

With pre-season approaching, securing a forward quickly will be crucial. Jota represents the kind of statement signing that could reignite Newcastle’s transfer momentum and ensure their Champions League campaign begins on the front foot.

Newcastle’s recruitment team faces a clear choice: gamble on a fading force in Calvert-Lewin or invest in a polished, elite-level operator in Jota. Given their ambitions, the latter is the only logical path forward.

The Magpies have the resources and the project to attract top talent. Now, they must prove they can close deals for the right players—not just the available ones. If they act decisively, Jota could be the catalyst for their next evolution under Eddie Howe.