Newcastle receive Giorgio Scalvini response after Atalanta big approach

The Magpies’ ambitious move for Atalanta’s prized center-back Giorgio Scalvini has encountered firm resistance from the Italian club, with conflicting reports emerging about the defender’s true availability.

Italian outlet TuttoAtalanta reveals Newcastle’s exploratory approach for the 21-year-old has been met with an initial “forceful rejection,” yet intriguingly suggests a potential pathway to negotiations if the right offer materializes.

Atalanta’s brass have reportedly branded Scalvini as “untouchable” following Newcastle’s inquiry, though the Bergamo-based publication curiously contradicts this stance by floating a potential €40-50 million (£35-42 million) price tag that could test their resolve.

This paradoxical response – simultaneously declaring the player off-limits while hinting at a valuation – reflects the delicate balancing act clubs face when coveted young talents attract Premier League interest.

The Italian international’s stock remains high despite an injury-disrupted campaign that saw him suffer consecutive setbacks – first an ACL rupture followed by a dislocated shoulder upon his return.

These fitness concerns have slightly dampened his market value, potentially creating a window of opportunity for Newcastle to secure a player once considered among Europe’s most promising defensive prospects.

The Magpies’ medical team will need to conduct rigorous assessments, but their successful gamble on Tino Livramento post-injury provides a reassuring precedent.

Scalvini’s technical profile makes him an enticing target for Eddie Howe’s system. Comfortable in both back-three and back-four setups, the 6’4″ defender combines aerial dominance with refined ball-playing abilities – attributes that could see him form an imposing long-term partnership with Sven Botman.

His eight senior caps for Italy and involvement in Atalanta’s 2024 Europa League triumph demonstrate maturity beyond his years, despite his recent injury woes.

The reported £35-40 million valuation presents an intriguing dilemma for Newcastle’s recruitment team. While exceeding Scalvini’s current market value according to Italian observers, the fee could represent shrewd business if the defender rediscovers his pre-injury form.

Atalanta’s participation in next season’s Champions League complicates negotiations, but their history of developing and selling talent suggests they may eventually entertain serious offers.

Newcastle’s interest has been corroborated by several reputable English sources including The Telegraph’s Luke Edwards and The Athletic’s Chris Waugh, indicating genuine intent behind their pursuit.

The club’s strategy appears focused on securing a right-sided center-back who can contribute immediately while possessing significant upside, with Scalvini’s age and potential resale value adding to his appeal.

As summer negotiations intensify, this transfer saga may develop into a test of Newcastle’s persuasion power versus Atalanta’s retention ambitions.

The Italian club’s mixed messages suggest their stance could soften for the right price, potentially creating an opportunity for the Magpies to land a defensive cornerstone who could anchor their backline for years to come.

With preseason preparations looming, Newcastle must weigh whether to meet Atalanta’s substantial demands or explore alternative targets in a market where quality young defenders command premium fees.