I scored a hat-trick against Newcastle and now they could sign me instead of Joao Pedro
Newcastle United’s summer transfer strategy is taking shape as the Magpies weigh up two exciting attacking options to bolster their Champions League squad.
With their pursuit of Brighton’s Joao Pedro progressing, Eddie Howe’s side have simultaneously identified Bournemouth’s Justin Kluivert as an intriguing alternative – a player who already knows how to find the net at St James’ Park.
The Brazilian forward Joao Pedro remains Newcastle’s primary target, with his versatility and Premier League experience making him an ideal candidate to provide cover and competition for Alexander Isak.
When comparing their 2024/25 Premier League campaigns, Pedro’s numbers demonstrate his potential to grow further in a more attacking system:
| Statistic | Joao Pedro | Alexander Isak |
|---|---|---|
| Starts | 23 | 34 |
| Goals | 10 | 23 |
| Assists | 6 | 6 |
| Expected Goals (xG) | 8.9 | 20.3 |
| xG Overperformance | +1.1 | +2.7 |
Pedro’s ability to outperform his expected goals tally suggests clinical finishing when chances arise – a trait that would likely flourish with increased service in Newcastle’s system.
His capacity to play across the frontline would also solve Howe’s recurring headache when Isak or Callum Wilson are unavailable, eliminating the need to deploy Anthony Gordon out of position.
However, Brighton’s £60 million valuation has prompted Newcastle to consider alternatives, with Justin Kluivert emerging as a compelling option at a potentially lower cost.
The Dutch international enjoyed a breakout season at Bournemouth, culminating in two hat-tricks – including one against Newcastle at St James’ Park. His €55m (£47m) price tag and proven Premier League pedigree make him an attractive alternative, with Bournemouth manager Andoni Iraola praising his development:
“Justin is obviously playing with confidence. For me the first goal is key – it’s a good transition but he had options to play both sides and he decides to take the shot. And it’s a great decision, a great finish.”
Key Considerations for Newcastle:
| Factor | Joao Pedro | Justin Kluivert |
|---|---|---|
| Transfer Fee | £60m | £47m |
| Premier League Goals | 10 | 12 |
| Positional Versatility | Striker/Winger | Winger/Attacking Mid |
| Age | 23 | 25 |
| St James’ Park Form | N/A | Hat-trick scorer |
Kluivert’s explosive end to the season, combined with his familiarity with the Premier League’s demands, presents Newcastle with a ready-made solution who could hit the ground running.
His ability to play multiple attacking roles would provide Howe with tactical flexibility in both domestic and European competitions.
As Newcastle navigate their return to Champions League football, this transfer decision could define their ability to compete on multiple fronts.
Pedro offers the higher ceiling and long-term potential, while Kluivert represents a more immediate impact at a reduced cost.
With PSR considerations still influencing their spending, the Magpies must carefully weigh whether to break the bank for their primary target or opt for the proven Premier League performer who has already demonstrated his capabilities on Tyneside turf.
The coming weeks will reveal whether Newcastle’s hierarchy shares Howe’s apparent preference for Pedro, or if Kluivert’s combination of affordability and proven quality makes him the more prudent investment as they look to strengthen without jeopardizing their hard-won financial stability.