Gary Neville slammed for ‘unbearable’ Newcastle reaction in Carabao Cup final win

Gary Neville, the Manchester United legend turned Sky Sports pundit, found himself at the center of attention during Newcastle United’s thrilling 2-1 victory over Liverpool in the Carabao Cup final.

While Neville’s commentary is often praised for its insight and passion, his reaction to Alexander Isak’s goal during the match has sparked criticism from fans.

As Isak fired Newcastle into a 2-0 lead with a clinical finish, Neville let out an elongated scream of “Ohhhhhhhhhh,” a reaction that drew comparisons to his infamous outburst during Fernando Torres’ iconic goal for Chelsea against Barcelona in 2012.

While Neville’s enthusiasm was evident, many viewers found his vocal response overbearing and unnecessary.

Fans took to social media to express their frustration, with one commenting, “I like Gary Neville in many respects, but his constant talking, quipping, ‘ooh’ and ‘aah’ over the commentator, especially in key moments, is highly irritating.”

Another added, “Yet again, Gary Neville got to do his unnecessary scream to get his voice heard. He is unbearable.” A third fan chimed in, “Can you get Gary Neville to take the microphone away from his mouth before he makes that noise for every single goal?”

Despite the criticism, Neville did go on to praise Isak’s goal, describing it as “special” and acknowledging the significance of the moment for Newcastle fans. “This is really special,” he said on Sky Sports. “They [the Newcastle fans] are almost crying, I’m almost crying for them. Alexander Isak, what a finish. What a game.”

The goal itself was a moment of pure quality, with Jacob Murphy heading the ball into Isak’s path before the Swedish striker unleashed a powerful shot into the net.

It was a goal that encapsulated Newcastle’s determination and skill on the day, and it put them firmly in control of the final. Earlier in the match, Dan Burn had opened the scoring with a brilliant header from a Kieran Trippier corner, sending the Newcastle faithful into raptures.

Despite a late consolation goal from Federico Chiesa in added time, Liverpool’s efforts fell short, and Newcastle held on to claim a historic victory.

For Newcastle, this win marked the end of a 54-year wait for a major trophy, their last coming in 1969. The scenes at Wembley were emotional, with players and fans alike overcome with joy.

Captain Bruno Guimarães, who delivered a commanding performance in midfield, was visibly moved after the final whistle. Speaking to Sky Sports, he described the win as “unbelievable” and dedicated the victory to the club’s loyal supporters.

“It’s all for these fans,” Guimarães said. “They deserve everything. When I first came here, I said I wanted to put my name in history. We can now say we are the champions again. This is one of the best days of my life.”

Guimarães went on to express his deep connection to the club and its fans, describing Newcastle as his “second home.”

He also revealed that he had received a message from club legend Alan Shearer before the game, further highlighting the significance of the occasion. “I don’t have any words. It’s the best day of my life. For them [the fans], it’s like the World Cup.

People have grown up and not seen us as champions. My first year as captain of this club, and it’s one of the best days. This is unbelievable. We are making history. Some day when I leave this club, I want the fans to sing my name the way they do to Shearer.”

The victory was a testament to the progress Newcastle have made under Eddie Howe, who has transformed the team into genuine contenders. For the fans, it was a moment of pure elation, a reward for decades of unwavering support.

While Gary Neville’s commentary may have divided opinion, there was no denying the magnitude of Newcastle’s achievement. This was a day that will live long in the memory of everyone connected with the club, a day when the Magpies finally ended their long wait for silverware and wrote a new chapter in their storied history.