Alan Shearer didn’t hesitate when asked to name the greatest player in Newcastle’s history

Alan Shearer, a name synonymous with Newcastle United, has revealed who he considers the greatest player in the club’s storied history. A legend in his own right, Shearer spent a decade at St James’ Park, scoring 260 goals in 405 appearances and still holding the record for the most goals in Premier League history.

His legacy at Newcastle is unmatched, with records that include being the club’s all-time leading scorer and the player with the most goals in European competitions. He also secured three consecutive Premier League Golden Boots between 1994 and 1997, further cementing his place among football’s elite.

Shearer made headlines in 1996 when he joined Newcastle as the world’s most expensive player in a £15 million transfer, a fee that, when adjusted for inflation, would have surpassed the record-breaking sum PSG paid for Neymar.

His ability on the pitch was so revered that Juventus manager Marcello Lippi instructed his forwards, including David Trezeguet, to study Shearer’s style, a testament to his reputation across Europe. Despite winning just one major club trophy, his influence on the game remains undeniable.

While most Newcastle supporters consider Shearer the greatest player in the club’s history, he believes a different player deserves that honor.

With a rich history of legends donning the black-and-white stripes—icons like Kevin Keegan, Paul Gascoigne, Bobby Moncur, Shay Given, and Hughie Gallacher—Shearer’s choice carries significant weight.

Surprisingly, he named Peter Beardsley as the greatest player ever to represent Newcastle, even ahead of the legendary Jackie Milburn.

During an episode of The Rest Is Football podcast, Shearer praised Beardsley’s extraordinary talent, stating, “I wouldn’t ever say myself, so Peter Beardsley, I think. He was unbelievable, he was a great player. I didn’t see Jackie Milburn, but certainly in my era, Peter Beardsley.”

Beardsley was known for his technical brilliance, intelligence on the ball, and ability to change a game in an instant. His influence extended beyond his statistics, though he managed 121 goals and 42 assists in 326 appearances across two spells with Newcastle.

He captained the team and was twice named the club’s Player of the Year. His excellence was recognized at the national level as well, with four selections in the PFA Team of the Year and an eventual induction into the English Hall of Fame.

While Beardsley shone in the modern era, Milburn’s contributions came in a different time but were equally impactful. A prolific striker from the 1950s, he remains the second-highest goalscorer in Newcastle’s history behind Shearer.

Growing up in the North East, he spent almost his entire career with the Magpies, leading them to three FA Cup triumphs in 1951, 1952, and 1955. His dedication and achievements earned him legendary status and, like Beardsley, a place in the Hall of Fame.

Shearer’s recognition of Beardsley over Milburn highlights how footballing greatness can be measured in different ways. While Milburn brought success and trophies to Newcastle, Beardsley’s technical ability and influence on modern football made him an unforgettable figure in Shearer’s eyes.

Both remain cherished figures in the club’s history, embodying the passion and talent that define Newcastle United.

While opinions may differ on who stands as the greatest Newcastle player of all time, Shearer’s words add weight to the argument for Beardsley. Both he and Milburn left an indelible mark on the club, ensuring their names will be remembered by generations of supporters.

Their contributions, whether through silverware or sheer brilliance on the pitch, remain a defining part of Newcastle’s rich history.